Should BYU fans be rooting for Utah?

This weekend's contest between BYU and Utah is probably the most anticipated game in the history of this rivalry so hopefully it lives up to expectations. Most games with this much hype turn out to be blowouts. There is a lot more on the line than bragging rights between family members. Major media outlets had been talking about this game even before the season began. In fact, why isn't this game covered on ESPN! Talk about a wasted opportunity to showcase its talent. The most important game in the history of the conference and only 2000 dish network subscribers will see the game on TV. Whatever the contract dispute, it shows some shortsightedness that needs to be reprimanded. Why not sign a one year deal just so that this game gets on TV? The problem with the Mtn is that it only reaches subscribers, which means you are a die hard MWC football fan already. The people you are trying to reach are general college football fans who are interested in a good game but wouldn't normally turn on a BYU game. How can you ever expect to recruit nationally if no one has even seen you play?

Final BCS scenarios.
So the non-BCS is looking like a 3 horse race with the finish line this weekend. Utah obviously has the clearest path. It controls its own destiny with computer numbers that Boise State can't match and a win preserves their lead in the Harris/Coaches polls. Utah might even leapfrog USC with an impressive win vs. BYU. Also, the Ok-Texas Tech game will determine if they jump a 2 loss Okalahoma. I doubt Texas Tech falls below Utah from a loss to a top 5 Oklahoma team.

Boise State is almost guaranteed the spot if Utah falls this weekend. They still have a semi-tough game against Nevada on the road. All they can do is win out and hope that Utah loses. Nevada played them well last year and more importantly, can a freshman quarterback really go undefeated? Going undefeated in even the worst conference is difficult. All it takes is one bad game. This is that bad game.

Ball State falling behind BYU last week was their virtual elimination from a BCS bowl. Even though Ball State plays a strong Central Michigan team helping their SOS, BYU's computer numbers will jump even more with a game against a #7 Utah, thus preserving their current lead if both teams win.

BYU needs to beat Utah and Boise State needs to lose one of the their last two games. It would be hard to rank a Utah team higher than a BYU team that just beat them and has the same number of losses. Boise State would probably fall 10 spots if they lose to any WAC opponent so that would place BYU around 12 in the polls, high enough to qualify for the automatic bid. They looked like they were finished a couple of week ago but all of the pieces might magically fall into place for them to get to their goal.

Long term outlook of non BCS teams
So looking past the immediate ramifications of a win or loss for either school, what would a win or loss mean for the long term. Part of that question is answered by another question. Setting all allegiances aside, which team would best represent the non-BCS in a bowl game?. In other words, who would have a chance at winning against a team like Oklahoma, Texas, or USC?

Boise State getting the bid is the least attractive option for the non-BCS. It has played the weakest schedule of the 3 schools and in one of the weakest conferences. It would be like Hawaii all over again but at least Hawaii had a Heisman Candidate in Colt Brennan that made the team interesting. A BCS bowl loss would only prove to detractors that non-BCS teams play bad teams and don't really belong there in first place. This might justify the eventual removal or stiffer requirements for automatic qualification for non-BCS teams. Of the three schools, it has the most modest chance of sustaining itself long term. The program is a young program with a lot of success that is dependent on their current coaching staff. It hasn't had the time to endure conference changes, coaches leaving, player scandals and the like that can tear a program down. The non-BCS doesn't need two hit wonders. What it needs are marquee teams that represent the group well. With all that being said, 2 BCS bowls in three years would be very impressive.

BYU getting the bid has its advantages and disadvantages. Getting a one loss team in would mean that the non-BCS had gained tremendous respect over the last few years. Nobody would ever have predicted that a one loss team would even qualify. A BYU win over a one loss team such as USC or Alabama in a bowl game would be a tremendous argument against the one loss handicap that the current non-BCS teams receive. It would justify the MWC's high rankings throughout the year and further the view the notion that it iis better than some of the BCS conferences. Sustaining that for two to three more years would provide legitimate credentials to gain entry into the BCS party. BYU also travels well and would bring its own fans to a game in any destination, especially Arizona. It also has the highest chance of sustainability as it is the best known program, the one with the most history and will be ranked in the top 15 next year in the preseason with many skill positions returning starters. The big down side is that not having an undefeated team is just not that exciting. An undefeated team makes it historic, David vs Goliath, a must watch college football game with a possibility of having an outside claim at the national championship. There is a sense of the unknown creating intrigue. A one loss team will be..well...boring for everyone outside of Utah.

I think that Utah getting the bid would create the most drama. It would have the best wins resume and it has some decent history on its side. Two BCS games with two different coaches shows sustainability. It would prove all of the things that a win by BYU provides but as an undefeated team. It could end up as high as 3d in the polls. If the national title game is close and Utah wins in a blowout, it could even get a few votes for #1 in the final AP poll. Finally, I think it is the best team all around, offense and defense that would give a good game to a BCS opponent. BYU also has had a horrific bowl history. Even last year's Las Vegas Bowl win was pretty pathetic considering UCLA wasn't even ranked.

Still, being a BYU fan you don't necessarily care for what is best for the conference, more what is best for your school so I can only hope BYU wins in a good game.
Prediction: Utah 28-BYU-21.